Whiskey brands named after criminal acts and individuals are nothing new. Likewise, it’s hardly uncommon to find a considerable number of bottles on store shelves that say some variation of “distilled in Lawrenceburg, IN.” Perhaps the most apt case of these two examples converging is with George Remus and, more specifically, Remus Repeal Reserve. Produced by Ross & Squibb (MGP), the Remus line is arguably the Indiana distilling giant’s most recognized in-house brand. This is especially so when considering the 2021 release of Repeal Reserve V, which brought together a blend of impressively aged bourbons, all with an agreeable price tag and level of availability.

Subsequent Remus Repeal Reserve releases haven’t been quite as impressive from a statistical standpoint, utilizing stocks that almost or just barely hit the decade mark in age. I’m of the mind that bourbon is usually at its best between 8-12 years. There are certainly exceptions, but the balance of grain to oak is often most enjoyable right around the 10-year mark. With that and the fact I haven’t tried any of the previous Repeal Reserve batches in mind, I’m curious to see what I think of the modestly received 2023 release. Like its predecessors, Repeal Reserve VII is comprised of a blend of 21% and 36% (both rye) bourbons, bottled at 50% ABV, and retails for around $100. The blend breakdown is as follows:

• 6% 2007 21% rye bourbon (16 years)
• 26% 2013 21% rye bourbon (10 years)
• 21% 2014 21% rye bourbon (9 years)
• 26% 2013 36% rye bourbon (10 years)
• 21% 2014 36% rye bourbon (9 years)

Nose: Honey, Candied Ginger, Butterscotch, Tobacco Leaf

Warm, Buttery, Balanced

Palate: Ginger Snaps, Orange, Caramel, Oak

Sweet, Thin, Creamy

Finish: Rye Spice, Barrel Char, Light Roast Coffee, Vanilla

Medium, Creamy, Warm

I historically have an on/off relationship with Ross & Squibb bourbons, but it typically leans on the off side. This is why I’m happy to say that Remus Repeal Reserve VII is a welcome, enjoyable pour. The profile is familiar but with just enough distinguishing characteristics to help the final product stand out. Even if marginally so. Actually, the nose on this bourbon is downright delightful, taking you through a pleasing assortment of candy and dessert notes that only gets better over time. The palate and finish aren’t as spectacular by comparison, partly due to the rather thin mouthfeel stunting the flavors. However, what really holds this whiskey together is an overall sense of balance; I think some Kentucky producers could learn a thing or two from this release.

Then there’s the bourbon boom question of value. Any bottle treading or exceeding the triple-digit range in the 2024 market has an uphill battle. Remus Repeal Reserve VII is no exception. For $100, I think the experience falls short a notch or two. Yet I’m also allowing my more critical side to speak there since, like most whiskey fans, my disposable income isn’t exactly fattening as of late. I wouldn’t feel robbed had I blindly purchased a bottle for $100, but I wouldn’t be itching to do the same with its successors, either.