Talisker 10-Year Scoresheet & Review

Whisky is very much a product of its environment. Wherever the aging spirit physically resides will impact how the final product comes out, from the surrounding climate to the casks used for maturation. One of the more interesting ways whisky can take on a unique personality is through coastal influences. And when it comes to maritime qualities, few brands will come to mind quicker than Talisker.

The Talisker distillery, formed in 1830, is located on Carbost and is the oldest working distillery on the Isle of Skye. “Where rugged coastlines meet the raging sea” is the brand’s key marketing pitch. Strictly speaking, this isn’t a disingenuous way to describe the whisky, as it’s often said to possess briny or otherwise salty characteristics. And although the whisky is also peated, it’s not to the same extent as its Islay-bred brethren. Taking up the flagship bottling mantle is the revered Talisker 10-Year. According to distiller.com, its peat level is around 16-22 PPM and mostly aged in ex-bourbon casks “constructed to a larger hogshead size.” Its bottling ABV is a bit higher than other flagship products at 45.8% and, in my experience, has highly volatile pricing depending on your market. The cheapest I’ve seen it for is just over $60, but $80 tends to be the more common asking price.

Nose: Cooked fruits by a dying campfire on the beach. Maybe some smoked meats in the background. Somewhat mulchy with a backbone of pear to keep things familiar. Generously honeyed white tea and lightly grilled pineapple. Post-sip sees the fruit and malt notes shine, but there’s still an approximation of hickory smoke in there.

Palate: Decently oily with a little brine and slow-building spice. Notes of pear and golden raisin amidst a fairly peppery profile. The core of the experience remains sweet and friendly despite its prickly flair.

Finish: Pepper spice peaks while wisps of pear come and go. Sea salt component shines as it sits, complemented by a gentle smoky presence.

It’s been a year since I reviewed Talisker Select Reserve Greyjoy, a bottle that instantly won me over and never faltered from neck to foot. I’m happy to report that the more available and ubiquitous 10-Year effectively checks the same boxes. I no longer have the aforementioned Greyjoy bottle to compare, but based on memory, I feel like the HBO tie-in had a bit more contributing to its relatively exciting experience. Not substantially, mind you, but enough to make a difference. However, this could also be due to my more impressionable palate at the time. Furthermore, I have more whisky (including scotch) under my belt, so the chances a flagship bottle would leave a big impact at this point are slim.

The good news is that these factors do little to detract from this being a great scotch for any time of the year. Spring and summer? The fruit notes will do the trick. Fall and Winter? Smoke and brine have me covered. Only one thing keeps this from being a likely staple on my bar—and it’s a common grievance of mine: pricing. As previously mentioned, I generally see Talisker 10-Year for $80 before tax. My budget has become more flexible over the past couple years, but $80 remains a staggering cost for a bottle of booze. I’m just glad I was able to try a 200ml in a Diageo Coastal Collection set that ultimately set me back $35, because the idea of blindly dropping $80 for a bottle of this absolutely treads regretful territory. $60 would be far easier to swallow for a recurring purchase, but there are still some strong hitters in that range, including Bunnahabhain and Highland Park 12-Year. The end result is that Talisker 10-Year is more a victim of my market than anything.

1 Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s